What The Tree Left Behind - Part One

By Benjamin Tousley, on behalf of his beloved dog Bear, in whose canine voice this piece is written.

I recently learned there are many different ways to lose something.

Before this, I suppose I thought loss was fairly simple. Something was there, and then it wasn't. A person walks through a door and doesn't come back. A toy disappears beneath a piece of furniture and is apparently lost forever because humans lack both the determination and the proper body shape to retrieve it. A squirrel vanishes into the woods before I can adequately explain my position on territorial boundaries.

There. Gone. Loss.

It turns out I did not understand it nearly as well as I thought I did.

My Man and I have been traveling quite a bit lately because of his work. I like being with him, and I have become an accomplished traveler. I know the truck, my place in it, and the particular sound of the tires changing from one kind of pavement to another.

Every couple of weeks we return to our place in the mountains of Tennessee. Every time we turn onto that familiar road, something inside me changes. My nose goes up. The window becomes much more interesting. There are smells you cannot mistake once they belong to you.

The woods. Damp earth. Fields. Old leaves. Deer. Rabbits. Cattle and horses from farms farther down the road. Sometimes woodsmoke. Sometimes wildflowers. Rain coming, if you know how to smell for it.

Home has a smell. Humans seem to have forgotten this.

When we arrive, I am released from most of the ridiculous regulations that govern dogs in what humans call civilization. I don't have to wear a collar or leash. Nobody becomes "concerned" when I walk through my own yard.

At home, I am simply Bear.

I run. I investigate the property. I check the trails and determine whether deer have been trespassing. They usually have. Then, when all matters requiring my expertise have been addressed, I find my favorite place beneath the big oak tree in the front yard.

It was a wonderful tree.

Its branches spread wide over the grass, creating a great pool of shade. Beneath it, the ground stayed cool, and I could stretch out in the grass and watch my Man work without having to participate in any meaningful way.

This was an arrangement I considered ideal.

My Man does not relax when we come home. He says he is going to relax, but he never does. Within an hour, he has changed clothes and begun wandering around with his hands on his hips. This inevitably leads to tools, which lead to projects, which lead to other projects.

Soon he is carrying, stacking, cutting, digging, repairing, hauling, or mowing.

He complains constantly.

"Bear, I've got too much to do."

"Bear, I'm never going to get all this done."

"Bear, I came down here to relax."

Then he keeps working.

I have developed a theory. He likes it.

Humans have a complicated relationship with happiness. Sometimes they appear happiest while complaining about the thing making them happy.

I watch him change after several hours outside. His shoulders loosen. His face changes. The telephone stops ringing. The glowing screens are inside the house. His hands get dirty. The world gets smaller.

I think the work grounds him.

Fortunately, I am already grounded. I am a dog. So I lie beneath my oak tree and supervise.

There was another reason I loved that tree: squirrels.

The oak had developed a serious squirrel problem. The squirrels undoubtedly believed it was their tree. This was incorrect. They had simply occupied it before anyone competent arrived to enforce the rules.

I would lie beneath the branches pretending to sleep, one ear turned toward the trunk. Eventually I would hear the faint scratch of tiny claws. My eyes would open. A tail would flick somewhere above me.

The negotiations would begin.

I never caught one. That is not the point. The point was that they knew I was there.

So yes, I loved that tree.

Loved.

I understand now that this is an important distinction.

The last time we came home, we were staying for an extended holiday weekend. My Man had lists. There were plans. There were lists about plans. He checked the weather repeatedly.

Clear. Sunny. Perfect weather for several days of uninterrupted work.

We arrived Friday evening and unloaded the truck. I conducted my usual inspection. Everything seemed normal.

Then the sky changed. The wind came hard across the property—not like an ordinary wind that moves through leaves, but as something with weight behind it. Something angry.

The trees bent. The windows rattled, then shook. Things struck the house. Branches flew across the yard. Rain came sideways against the windows. The front door actually buckled inward.

That frightened me.

There are sounds in nature that speak directly to the oldest part of a dog. They require no explanation.

Danger. Find shelter. Stay close.

The electricity went out. The familiar house became dark while the world outside roared. I stayed near my Man, every crash making me flinch.

Then came a sound unlike the others.

A deep, heavy crack.

Not the snap of a branch, but a tearing sound—enormous and final.

Then came the impact.

I knew before I saw it.

My tree.

The great oak had broken roughly halfway up its trunk. Everything above the break had crashed into the front yard, its enormous crown spread across the grass where I had spent so many afternoons beneath its shade.

I stared through the window.

Trees stand. That is what trees do. They are among the few things you expect to find tomorrow exactly where you found them yesterday.

But mine was lying on the ground.

My Man looked at it and shook his head. Then he said several words I have decided not to include in this account.

After that, he went to bed.

The world was apparently ending, half the yard had blown away, my tree had been destroyed, and this man decided there was nothing he could do about it in the dark, so he might as well sleep.

Sleep?

I followed him into the bedroom partly because I wanted to stay near him and partly because I wanted to observe this level of insanity firsthand.

Another gust struck the house. Something crashed outside. He pulled up the covers, closed his eyes, and somehow fell asleep.

I remained awake considerably longer.

To be continued . . .

© by Benjamin R Tousley

Your feedback is welcome! Please feel free to leave a comment or a question, or share a tip, a related article or a resource of your own in the Comments section below. If you’d like Grief Healing Blog updates delivered right to your inbox, you’re cordially invited to subscribe to our weekly Grief Healing Newsletter. Sign up here


When Grief Is Too Much to Bear: Supporting A Grieving Parent, from A Distance

A parent’s love is whole, no matter how many times divided. ~ Robert Brault

A reader writes: My husband and I are dealing with his mother's grief over losing his father (her husband), who passed away last month in a wonderful hospice in another state. I have visited your online grief support website, and although it helps calm my nerves somewhat to see that other widows are experiencing the same acute grief emotions as my mother-in-law, we are at a loss for how to help and support her most effectively when she is in one state and we live in another. We are concerned that she definitely needs one-on-one grief counseling, but she is so distraught that she cannot even call her doctor and arrange it, or even speak with the wonderful, supportive people at the hospice there. What can we do from a distance?

You Can’t Take Away Their Grief, But You Can Be There

Above all, show your love. Show up. Say something. Do something. Be willing to stand beside the gaping hole that has opened in your friend’s life, without flinching or turning away. Be willing to not have any answers. Listen. Be there. Be present. Be a friend. Be love. Love is the thing that lasts.  ~ Megan Devine

If this is your first encounter with someone who is mourning, you are wise to learn more about the grief experience and to let go of some of the harmful myths you may have heard about grief and healing. Don’t assume that someone who seems to be experiencing little pain or sorrow is “doing well” with grief. Take some time to reflect on your own experiences of death and grief. Recall who died, what was helpful and unhelpful to you, and how you felt during that time.

If any of the suggestions offered here don’t fit with a particular culture or tradition, or if they don’t seem appropriate for you or the person you want to help, simply set them aside and consider the others.

As soon as you learn that a death has occurred, there are several things you can do right away:

When Grief Takes Away Everything That Was Normal

There is something about losing a mother that is permanent and inexpressible—a wound that will never quite heal. ~ Susan Wiggs

A reader writes: My mom died of cancer three months ago after seven years of fighting. I am 22 years old, and I feel as though I have lost everything that was normal. I miss my mom so much. She was my very best friend. I just need someone to talk to who understands. I feel so alone.

I am a Christian, and my faith helps a lot, but I literally don't have anyone. My dad had to move away. My boyfriend of three and a half years broke up with me one week after the funeral, and my friends are too involved with college and partying. I feel like I have been robbed.

Grieving Without Numbing The Pain

Frequency of drinking is less important than the role that alcohol plays in the life of the grief victim.— Margaret Gerner

A reader writes: It's been a terrible and bumpy ride so far. Yesterday I wasn't too bad—at least not after I saw my grief counselor. This morning I drove our eldest son and his wife to the airport so they could return to their studies in the U.S. I've had all three children, plus one daughter-in-law, with me this past month. We were all at my husband's bedside when he died.

I made the trip to the airport fine. I was able to concentrate on the road, say goodbye without too many tears, and drive home again. Altogether, it was a four-hour trip. When I got home from the airport, I collapsed into tears. It was still early, so the two sons who are staying with me—for now—were still asleep. I took a sedative, then had a glass of wine, followed by another. Nothing helped.

I never drink in the morning. I'm not even usually a drinker, and I'm not the type to use sedatives or sleeping pills. Now I'm wondering if I'm headed down the road to addiction.

Hospice Care Doesn’t End With Death

Endings matter, not just for the person but, perhaps even more, for the ones left behind.  — Atul Gawande

In his article, Demystifying Hospice Care, medical news and information reporter William Stroh argued that hospice organizations need to do a better job of informing the public about the services they provide. He urged them “to fire up a dialogue with people in their community about hospice care” and to “engage with the community on a regular basis through popular sharing sites such as Facebook and Twitter.”

I couldn’t agree more. Through such efforts, I hope more patients and their families will come to understand that when a life-limiting illness no longer responds to treatment aimed at a cure, they can turn to hospice for the comfort, care, and support they need.

But did you also know that your local hospice organization may be one of your best sources of bereavement information, comfort, and support—both before and after a death?

Living With Loss Without Living in Grief

Trying to forget someone you love is like trying to remember someone you never met.  ~ Unknown

A reader writes: It's been a week since the fifth anniversary of my Mum's passing. Since then, I have found that I'm trying to forget about it. Putting it to the back of my mind and hoping it doesn't appear in a conversation. Is that wrong? It’s also been six months since I visited the cemetery, but it's not because I find it hard to go there, I suppose I feel that it's not important to. Is that wrong?

Keeping Their Ashes Close: Finding Comfort in Personal Remembrance

The kind of "blind obedience" once theologized as the ultimate step to holiness, is itself blind. It blinds a person to the insights and foresight and moral perspective of anyone other than an authority figure. — Sister Joan D. Chittister, OSB

Recently I came across a Facebook post linking readers to an article titled Vatican: No more scattering of cremation ashes. The article described the Vatican's recently reaffirmed (though long-standing) guidelines for Roman Catholics who choose cremation. According to those guidelines, cremated remains are not to be scattered, divided among family members, or kept at home. Instead, they are to be laid to rest in a place the Church recognizes as sacred.

The passionate responses the post generated reminded me of an exchange I had some time ago with a member of our online Grief Healing Discussion Groups.

When Does Grieving End?

Grief comes in three stages: the beginning, the middle, and the rest of your life.  ~ Candace Lightner

A reader writes: I have been reading a wonderful little book called Healing After Loss by Martha Hickman. It contains brief, one-page daily reflections to help people work through their grief.

Today's reading centered on this thought: "Sometimes the best choice is to be in my grief, sometimes not."

The author suggests that we can become so accustomed to living in a grieving state that, in some ways, it feels more comfortable than making the effort to step away from it.

When You've Lost Both Parents: Coping With Anger, Despair and Grief

At midnight, even bad days come to an end.  ~ Ms Moem

A reader writes: I lost both my parents and it sucks. My father died before I even graduated from college. For me, I wanted to make my parents proud by going to college, and getting a good paying job and helping them out financially. My father died before I even graduated, and he never saw me off to my real professional job. Life seemed pointless. My dream was killed. A part of me died. Our family was broken. We had to find a way to hold the table up with one person short. At that point, I realized that the most important thing to me was to spend as much time as I could with family, especially my mom, since she was hurting so much because she lost her companion. She became my best friend and we did everything together. And I was happy. I just wanted time with my family. And then last month my mother passes away. I'm so shocked I can't believe it. Now what I lived for, just got killed again.