A reader writes: I can't believe that it has been almost a year since the passing of our beloved 19 year old cat Mittens. With your help and words of support I was able to cope much better and to this day I still feel the hurt of her loss. I still miss her so much. My wife and daughter want another cat but for some reason I feel as if I can't or I am not ready. I know she can never be replaced and she will always be in my heart. Maybe I am being selfish to my family and to another cat who would have a good home. I have a lot of mixed feelings and not sure what to do. Thank you for listening to me again and God bless you.
My response: It's so nice to hear from you again, my friend. I truly do appreciate your struggle. After my dog Muffin was struck by a car and later euthanized, it took me ten years before I was ready and willing to let another dog into my home and into my heart. Fortunately for me, at the time this happened, my sons were grown and out of the nest, and my husband felt the same way I did about being "dog-less" for that length of time. But everyone is different in this regard, and I think it's important to recognize and allow for those differences, especially within your own family.
You say you have lots of mixed feelings about this, and I suspect that part of your reluctance to get another kitty is your fear is that you will have to go through all this pain again when you love and lose another cat at some future point. I can tell you that the one sure way to avoid repeating the pain you're feeling now is to decide never to love like that again. Yet you know (in your head, if not your heart) that whenever we take a companion animal into our lives, sooner or later we are going to lose that animal, simply because their life span is so much shorter than our own. We like to think our animals will be with us forever, but deep down we know that cannot be. This reality is very hard for us to accept when we are confronted with the death of our cherished animals. It is far better to acknowledge that harsh reality when we opt to bring an animal into our lives in the first place.
In addition, your sense of loyalty to Mittens might be interfering with your willingness to let yourself love another animal companion. Oftentimes we confuse loving another pet with "replacing" the one we've lost, and you may think that no other cat could replace your precious Mittens. It feels like an act of disloyalty, a violation of your cat's memory, an intrusion. After all, no other kitty could ever be like the one you lost. No other cat will have Mittens' unique qualities, nor should you expect it to. But instead of viewing another kitty as a "replacement,” it may help to think of this as making a new friend, one that you will learn about and come to love over time.
Is there any room for compromise here? What would happen if you simply accept the fact that you're not ready for another kitty without judging yourself for feeling that way, but since your wife and daughter feel differently about it, you could agree to let THEM get another cat or kitten -- with the understanding that you are allowed to feel your feelings without judgment, even to the extent that you'll have nothing to do with the new kitty, if that's how you need to play it? Then see how it goes? Only you know if that approach would work in your family, but it seems to me that if everyone is open and honest with one another in this situation, there ought to be a solution here that would meet everyone's needs, including your own.
For what it's worth, when my Muffin died I was shattered and absolutely heart-broken. I knew I could never, ever love another dog the way that I loved him. But ten years later we did get another dog, a Tibetan terrier named Beringer ~ and I must tell you that both my husband and I loved this dog as much as, if not more than, we'd ever loved any other creature (human or animal), and I could write a book about how much this dog meant to both of us. When you are by nature an animal lover and you lose the animal you love more than anything, I truly do believe that your heart is big enough to accommodate another ~ I have learned that through my own experience. Animals like cats and dogs just have a way of working their way into our hearts, probably because they are so innocent, so in the moment, so willing to give us that unconditional love that we never get from another human being.
But I also think you have to be ready, and willing, and open enough to let it happen. Only you will know when it is time ~ and there is nothing wrong with that. I just think that in a family, it's important to make room for the feelings of other members, and we can't expect everyone to feel the same way we do about important matters such as this. That's why I encourage you to consider how you might reach a compromise with your wife and daughter about their wanting to get another kitty ~ and whatever you decide, I wish you all the best.
Your feedback is welcome! Please feel free to leave a comment or a question, or share a tip, a related article or a resource of your own in the Comments section below.
If you’d like Grief Healing Blog updates delivered right to your inbox, you’re cordially invited to subscribe to our weekly Grief Healing Newsletter. Sign up here.
- How to Defeat Sadness Over the Loss of Your Animal In One Easy Step
- Finding Support for Pet Loss
- Am I Crazy for Feeling So Sad About This?
- Losing a Cherished Pet: Myths and Misconceptions
- Understanding Different Mourning Patterns In Your Family
- Life After Death by Ashley Davis Bush
- When You Are Still Suffering Years After Pet Loss by Marianne Soucy
- A Dog's Last Will and Testament